Yusuf Kemal Kasideci
← All writings

Culture & Society

Judge or Learn

Re-Considered by Yusuf Kemal Kasideci ·

Summary: Never judge, instead, understand and gain information. Then use that information to make the best decision. Judging keeps you busy doing nothing useful while you miss out on critical information right under your nose.


 

As humans, we like to think we know what other people are going through. The truth is: We have no idea. Yet, we continue to pass judgements onto people, as if we have a complete picture of their life. Our judgements feel legitimate for us, because the validity of the reasoning we employed is based on our relevant personal experience.


Now, I want you to close your eyes for a moment. Imagine a serial killer breaking into a house, and murdering an old lady inside. He then leaves no trace of his crime and climbs down the emergency stairs. As he rushes down, he notices a kid about to drown, and runs to save him from the river.

“Thank you, sir,” the kid cries back as he tries to hug the man—unaware of the murder this man had just committed.


I know it sounds like an extreme story, but it illustrates a powerful point. Judging is all relative. To the boy, the man is a hero. To the old lady, he’s a killer. So who are we to judge? Just as one man’s trash is another’s treasure; one person’s killer is another's savior.


And this nicely leads us to another important point we often ignore. Who are we to judge? Who’s to say your standard is perfectly—or even fairly—calibrated? Good and evil are all relative. To a saint, a law-abiding stripper at a nightclub is evil; but to a serial killer, that same lawful stripper is deemed ‘good.’ Again, who is to say who is good and who is evil? It all depends on the starting point of the observer and the standard at which their values are calibrated — and that is anything but an objective metric by which to judge anybody.


 


Whenever someone does us harm, we are always given two choices: Judge or Learn.


Judging is easy; it takes no accountability, no effort, no understanding. And in the 21st century, we have successfully become professors in judging, yet kindergartners in learning. We’ve normalised dismissing another person as ‘horrible’ just because they don’t share our opinion. We judge others based on what we think is happening, only to then turn into avid collectors of resentment against their behaviour. Yet, we rarely ask the questions that would open our minds to the truth: Where does that lead us? How does that help? And what does it solve?


But there’s an alternative perspective; a new path for us to tread—only if we’re willing to. Appearances can often be deceiving in life. Nothing is truly as it initially seems. Instead of seeing a certain person as ‘horrible’, you can choose to look for the hidden meaning behind their behaviour. You can ask “What does this person’s actions tell me about them? What information can I glean about their current or past emotional states simply from observing their behaviour without judgement?”


Because if we choose to judge them, what do we actually learn?

What do we gain?


NOTHING.


But if we override our impulse to judge and instead see the behaviour we’re observing as information, we give ourselves the chance to use that information to then make better, more helpful decisions. The problem with judging is that it keeps us busy doing absolutely nothing, all while we miss out on critical information right in front of us—information that could tip the scales in our favour or vastly transform outcomes.


For example, a friend yells at you, or your partner says something hurtful. You can either choose to judge her as ‘hurtful’ and ‘insensitive’, or you can choose to see her behaviour as just another piece of information that provides you with valuable insights into her internal state, which you can then use to act accordingly. For instance, you’d go from “Agh! She’s being so rude. Can’t she see she’s hurting me?” to “Ok, she seems to be having a bad day. What can I do to support her or make her feel better?”


In this example, a simple shift in how you perceived someone else’s behaviour completely changed how you interpreted it; which, in return, transformed your response from one of justified judgement to one of compassionate curiosity—from a response that separates, to one that brings you closer together. Empathy isn’t something we have to find, it’s something we already have within us at all times. All we have to do is remove the barriers that prevent us from acting with that empathy.


Arguing with the universe is a fool's errand. For when we do so, we surrender our wellbeing. We are masters at sabotaging our inner peace. Picking up unnecessary and senseless fights with reality has us continually setting ourselves up for disappointment. There is strength in the courage to say "This is not how I'd have done it. It’s not what I would've done. But it is as valid a choice as any other."


When we show the decency and maturity to show up in such a way that honors the other person's right to choose for themselves, provided it doesn't hurt us, we then allow our hearts to open. It is in such wisdom that we can connect authentically with the other person, with no judgement or separation.


The cost of judgement doesn't end with a lost opportunity for empathy, though. The burdensome onus of having to judge others constantly, which we fecklessly and oftentimes unconsciously foist upon ourselves, makes us incessantly weary and irritated. Chronic judgement deprives us of our inner curiosity and makes us cynical and mistrusting of the world around us. This only serves to blast us hurtling towards depression and ensnares us in a death spiral of fear that eats away at our inner peace and happiness, bringing weariness and misery to our lives.


You can’t really know anyone’s actual intentions by inference. Nothing is truly as it seems on the surface. There’s always so much more going on behind the scenes and behind closed doors. There’s always a hidden story, hiding in the background, beyond the veil, veneered behind the scenes; a story that you may never know, but one which if you knew, your view would transform entirely, because that story contains the full picture you lack.


Judging is critical, while observing is educational. Our opinions and thoughts are based on our very limited knowledge of the subject matter, and so will spur us onto dangerous haste as we impetuously rush into conclusions and assumptions. Because when we don’t know the full story, we tend to fill in those gaps in that incomplete story with what we think makes sense to us based on our world view, outlook on life, biases and convictions. Never should you lecture a man on how to tie his laces when you've never been in his shoes.


The one who knows only one side of the story knows nothing of that, said John Stuart Mill. And in any case, how can we judge someone based on our worldview?


 


Judgement is an optional choice, not a mandatory obligation. So, perhaps, instead of focusing on how ‘rude’ or ‘hurtful’ or ‘bad’ someone is, you should redirect your attention to what that tells you—to the information it reveals to you about the other person. And if you do this often enough, it will eventually become your mindset. And from then on whenever something bad is done to you, your default way of handling it will be to follow an information-gathering process instead of closing off your mind with senseless, useless, and insidious judgements.


Because when we approach life with the genuine curiosity of a detective, we become seekers of truth instead of collectors of resentment. And along the way, we continue to ask the question: "Is this really necessary?"

Further reading

Culture & Society

Why No One is Actually Evil.

"No man chooses evil because it's evil. he only mistakes it for happiness, the good he seeks."— Mary Wollstonecraft Nowadays, many of us tend to think that the people in power are evil. They reduce complex human beings into simple labels and call it discernment. Granted, we shouldn't deny nor downplay the evident malignity of warmongers or genocidal regimes. However, even then, the truth reveals itself as more nuanced and complex than we'd like to believe. Hear me out. There seems to be little

Culture & Society

The Human on the Other Side

We often get lost in our roles and identities, and we fail to see that there's another fellow human being on the other side. I'm sure there's somebody out there who you dislike or even despise. But will you still frown upon them when you think about the following?Whoever that person is, they want the same things that you do. If you want a home, they do too. You feel you need love? So do they. You require security and safety for your family, just like they do. You strive to be successful in your

Culture & Society

The Fount of Unlikely Wisdom & How to Find It

There’s something to learn from everybody. We often find ourselves with people who disagree with us and simply decide that we shouldn't listen to them. Consequently, we end up deliberately squandering away valuable opportunities to learn something new. We often neglect to see, however, that everyone’s experience grants them a unique perspective that is neither right or wrong. Every person, thanks to their unique experiences, is uniquely positioned and best placed to resolve problems in their ow